You’ve probably heard about this social media site where bots pretending to be people post AI-generated slop to each other, regurgitate nonsensible propaganda, make up inflammatory stories and engage with cryptocurrency scammers ramping worthless digital “assets”. It’s called “X”.
Meanwhile, there’s another social media site called “Moltbook” where people pretending to be bots post AI-generated slop to each other, regurgitate nonsensible propaganda, make up inflammatory stories and engage with cryptocurrency scammers ramping worthless digital “assets”. That’s progress for you. Only a few days in and the Moltbook “leaderboard” was already largely given over to cryptoscams of one form or another with the occassional bot swarm coming up the ranks.
The Information said that other than being incredibly entertaining and slightly worrying for those concerned about AI gaining sentience, OpenClaw and Moltbook “offer a glimpse of where AI is going”. Actually, that wasn’t the lesson I took away from my first look at what was going on over there. The lesson that I took away from (you will not be surprised to hear) is that without a working digital identity infrastructure, we can’t have nice things.
(Anyway bot swarms and other forms of what I think I remember Mark Zuckerberg once describe as “co-ordinated inauthentic behaviour” are not amusing. They are insidious.)
John Naughton summarised the situation very well indeed in a recent Observer column. As he wrote, much of what goes on in social media is real (by which he means genuine conversations between humans) but nobody really knows how much. This matters because the erosion of trust between what’s real and what’s manufactured is making democracies ungovernable.
(Incidentally, last year John drew my attention to an excellent rant from Dave Winer about the infuriating tendency of chatbots to pretend that they’re your friend.
“Can we have a rule,” Dave wrote, “that AI bots must by default behave like a computer?
We could adopt the conventions of Paranoia, the dystopian science-fiction tabletop role-playing game (first published in 1984), and require all posts by bots to end with “the computer is your friend”. But if that doesn’t work, it might be time to start using some actual cryptography.)
You know what I am going to say here, of course: without digital identity, verifiable credentials and immutable reputation, there is no good outcome. I don’t think that is controversial. But how?
xxx
The recent rapid acceleration of generative AI and the imminent prospect of more ubiquitous agentic AI systems—artificial intelligence software capable of autonomously performing complex tasks, making decisions, and interacting convincingly—has renewed interest in digital identity writ large. Agentic AI is projected to become more prevalent in the immediate future, as human users proactively delegate tasks to credentialed agents.
From: Lessons from National Digital ID Systems for Privacy, Security, and Trust in the AI Age | TechPolicy.Press.
xxx
xxx
Digital identity is the missing layer of the internet. Without it, everything we build rests on sand.
From: Digital identity is the infrastructure crisis no one admits.
xxx