xxx
According to the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation’s (FDIC’s) most recent report, 7.1 million households (5.4%) in the United States fit the definition of unbanked. The same holds true for 14 million individuals, or 5.5% of the adult population.
While these numbers are staggering, they actually reflect a downward trend in the number of unbanked households and individuals in the U.S. In fact, they represent the lowest level of individuals and households without a checking or savings account since the FDIC initiated its unbanked study over a decade ago.
From Banking the Unbanked: How to Become Part of the Solution.
xxx
xxx
The federal government struggled to get stimulus funds into the pockets of the nation’s unbanked during the pandemic. In a recent PaymentsJournal article, Mercator Advisory Group Director of Debit and Alternative Products Advisory Service, Sarah Grotta, discussed this issue.
“Much has been written in the popular media about how difficult it has been to distribute stimulus funds to all eligible recipients quickly. There are two central reasons for this: a) individuals do not trust the federal government with their checking account credentials that could facilitate a fast and safe direct deposit of funds, and b) they don’t have an account,” she wrote.
From Banking the Unbanked: How to Become Part of the Solution.
xxxxxx
The plight of the unbanked has been used to justify all sorts of government fixes: a Federal Reserve-issued digital currency, FedAccounts, postal banking, a USPS prepaid card, and a public Venmo. At the core of all these projects is the idea that unbanked Americans are unbanked because of excessive fees and high minimum account balance requirements. And that theory may be right, to a degree.
But none of these projects tries to account for people who may be unbanked for the same reason they don’t want to be vaccinated, or because they believe in QAnon. One of the motivating ideas behind FedAccounts, for instance, is to have the Federal Reserve provide a public option for the unbanked. But it could be that folks who are philosophically opposed to banks will also be intolerant of an account at the FED. God know the U.S. is rife with central banking conspiracy theories.
This may be one reason why places like Walmart are the best option for reaching the unbanked. Walmart isn’t a bank, so it can attract bank skeptics. And it has the financial heft to offer those on a low income a set of well-priced banking products via its Walmart MoneyCenters (which offer check cashing, bill pay, and money orders) and its prepaid debit card, the MoneyCard. Many of the 5.4% of the population that FDIC categorizes as unbanked are happily getting financial services at Walmart. They aren’t really unbanked; they are differently banked.
If not the Fed, perhaps the United States Postal Office is the right institution for reaching the philosophically unbanked. The USPS is not a bank. And according to Morning Consult, the post office is the most trusted brand in America. When asked how much do you trust each brand to do what is right? 42% of Americans responded that they trusted the USPS “a lot.” And so people who bristle at the idea of keeping a Chase debit card in their wallet may very well be proud owners of a USPS card.
From Moneyness: Why are so many Americans content to be unbanked?:
xxx
Unbanked is not the problem, and banks are not the solution
The CEO of PayPal, Dan Schulman, has said that one of the benefits of digital currency is inclusion and that the adoption of such digital alternatives to cash would benefit millions of unbanked Americans. But why is this? Why would the use of digital cash help people who are excluded?
The millions of Americans who are unbanked (or underbanked) are not in that position because there is a shortage of banks. Quite the reverse, in fact. America has thousands of banks. So clearly a lack of banks isn’t the problem. There must be some other problem. Why don’t the millions of unbanked people use PayPal instead?
As Wired magazine pointed out, basic bank accounts (which are mandated by the UK government) are accessible to those with poor credit histories, while challenger banks including Revolut and Monzo do not usually ask potential customers for proof of address in order to open an account. So it seems reasonable to ask why almost two million British adults do not have a bank account.