Piotr Jan Pietrzak, Director of International Development at BLIK, the innovative Polish payment system.
Why there are doubts about EPI
EPI makes sense from a global competition standpoint, as the major cross-border retail payments infrastructures used by Europeans are owned by US companies. In addition, highly fragmented local payments don’t have the economies of scale to be competitive in today’s globalized world. However, despite all the effort, EPI success is questionable. In my opinion there are a number of reasons why yet another Pan-European payment project has underdelivered so far:
Too ambitious. It’s a long shot to address at the same time all types of retail transactions including in-store, online, cash withdrawal and peer-to-peer. It put EPI in direct competition not only with US card schemes, but also tech giants like Apple and Google. For sure, focusing now only on instant payments makes it more feasible.
Many unknowns. Many key areas aren’t fully addressed, among them: funding sources, role of local networks, consumer adoption strategy, governance, operating model, and many more. The recent brief announcement doesn’t change that.
No credible commitment. Banks fear replacing established payment systems with an unproven alternative. There is no clear plan on how to incentivise migration, or at least it’s not well communicated.
Limited communication. Since the announcement of EPI, no visible progress has been made. The initiative has increased the number of participating banks to 33, but there was no clear plan of how the project would be executed. Now there are 13 backers, which is less than the number of founding partners, and fewer voices might improve decision-making.
Chicken and egg dilemma. EPI needs merchants ready to accept payments and users ready to make payments. Having both in place at the same time is not an easy task.
EPI might be seen as a company that reinvents the wheel, they ambitiously aim to create a viable pan-continental payment system from scratch, when Europe might have an already existing solution to the problem.
From Can Europe ever get its payment act together? – Chris Skinner’s blog:
xxx