China’s state-owned telecoms operator China Mobile, put forward proposals for a “Digital Identity System” for all users of the Metaverse at the second meeting of the International Telecommunications Union (ITU) Metaverse Focus Group in Shanghai in July 2023. (The ITU is a United Nationa agency and plays influential role in defining the ground rules for global telecommunications). The Chinese operator said that the digital ID should work with “natural characteristics” and “social characteristics” that include a range of personal data points like people’s occupation, “identifiable signs” and other attributes. They also suggested this information be “permanently” stored and shared with law enforcement “to keep the order and safety of the virtual world.”
(The proposals even provides the example of a noxious user called Tom — an ideal stand-in for whoever uses the fledgling technology, for instance for gaming or socializing — who “spreads rumors and makes chaos in the metaverse”; the digital identity system would allow the police to promptly identify and punish him.
We do of course need a means to take credentials associated with sovereign identity and use them in the Metaverse, but the special case of a virtual identity of Alice’s that is a homonym of her physical identity Alice (eg, her passport) should be seen as just that: a special case. Generally speaking, we do not see sovereign identities at the heart of the Metaverse.